This website is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission.



The good

Built with a long slot design, this model is easily among the top 4 slice toasters on the market.

This machine comes with seven shade settings that enable customized levels of cooking.

The toaster offers simplicity in use and convenient clean ups.

The toaster is always effortless to use.

Control is easy with the round knob and lever.


The bad

One of the KitchenAid KMT4116CU 4 slice toaster reviews bemoans the fact that you should toast the same kind of bread in the slots at the same time, not different types of bread. However, it is unusual to find a toaster that can accommodate two different types of bread simultaneously.

Buy from for ($99)



My opinion on this product


This is the best toaster from KitchenAid that can accommodate a variety of sizes and shapes of artisan bread. This means you won’t be limited to the standard size of bread slices that you can toast using this kitchen appliance. The slots are also engineered to be 1.5 inches wide to take in different bread types. With this toaster, there’s no need to cut long bread slices just to have them fit into the slots. The appliance lets you enjoy specialty breads toasted to perfection.


The toaster has a Bagel feature, which allows you to get perfectly toasted bagels that are crispy on the cut side and nicely warmed on the round side. The Defrost setting enables you to cook bread taken straight out of the freezer to bring it to the right temperature and toast it at the same time. The Reheat function lets you warm toast that has gone cold without burning the bread. The Keep Warm setting ensures that the toast is kept at a nice temperature for three minutes after toasting without overcooking.


The toaster provides simple start and finish so you won’t have to wait for a long time for the unit to pre-heat. The high-lift lever enables you to take out the bread easily after cooking, which effectively prevents you from getting your fingers burned. You can extract smaller pieces of bread easily without using tongs or other implements. The two rugged steel, double-width crumb trays are easy to clean, so you simply pull them out and clean off the bits and pieces of bread collected, or place the trays in the dishwasher. The toaster features under-base cord storage that keeps the power cable neatly stored when the toaster is not in use.


The toaster is equipped with seven different shade settings that you can choose from, so you can enjoy precise cooking every time. Choose the level of toasting you prefer every time. The high lift lever allows you to check the progress of the toasting process any time without switching the equipment off completely. The KitchenAid KMT4116CU 4 slice toaster automatically cycles through each selected function so you won’t have to figure out what will come next.


Offering extraordinary style and durability, the KitchenAid KMT4116CU 4 slice toaster has easy controls via a lever for the Toast Boost function and a knob to choose the level of toasting. Just push the button at the center of the control knob to cancel the toasting process. The Defrost, Bagel and Keep Warm functions are activated using the simple buttons on the machine.



Boasting an all-metal construction, the KitchenAid KMT4116CU 4 slice toaster has a painted, smudge-resistant metal housing that ensures easy wipe-clean maintenance. You’ll love the cool styling and innovative features that can give higher priced models a run for the money.


Buy from for ($99) Protection Status