This website is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission.


The Essential Guide to Finding the Best Toaster Oven for Baking + Reviews


Looking for the best toaster oven that’s great when it comes to baking can be quite difficult, but Grandma Jen is definitely someone you can count on to make your search a little bit easier. She recommends the Hamilton Beach 31126 because of its compact size and nifty little features. This toaster oven has a roll-top door so you can easily check and remove the contents of the oven without risking to spill anything. Also, because of the basic three cooking settings, roast, broil, and – most important – bake, and because the oven is a convection one, you will be able to cook the food you want and how you want it, as well. The baking pan is 9 x 11 inches, and the oven can also easily fit a 12-inch pizza in it. But if you can’t find the Hamilton Beach 31126 in stock, the next best option you should be aiming for should be the Black+Decker TO3250XSB as it is reliable and can provide you with the help you need around the kitchen.



Comparison table


The Good
The Bad



Our Comprehensive Buying Guide


While searching for toaster ovens for baking, you might stumble upon a myriad of models that are not exactly for baking. Therefore, you might also find reviews of toaster ovens for baking that will tell you to look for features that are not even required if baking is your one true goal.

To shrink down the number of options you may find or have, below you’ll find a list of things that you should take into account when searching for the best toaster oven for baking.

What type of toaster oven for baking to choose

As mentioned before, there are a lot of these products out there on the market. You can find your usual option, then the convection oven, the rotisserie, and the infrared toaster oven. However, you are here to find the perfect toaster oven for baking, of course – and for that, what you should look for is the one that has the three basic features of bake, toast, and broil.

Choose one that has extra functions only if you plan on doing something else than baking. But if you plan to do mainly baking, then a convection oven could be just the right choice. That’s because the convection technology spreads the heat equally throughout the oven so that your baked goods will be cooked properly on all sides, width, and length.


Proper size and space

After determining the type of appliance you want to have and, therefore, narrowing down your list of options, you should look at their sizes and then at the place you have available for them in your kitchen.

This is very important because they must not fit perfectly in that certain space – a perfect fit means that it’s too crowded and tight for them. When measuring the place you want to put them in, you’ll want to leave some extra space on the sides, but most importantly in the back and above. This is required so that the toaster oven operates properly.

Also, you might know that they do generate quite some heat, especially above and through the back — that’s why you should never plan to put something on them or having them too close to your suspended cabinet. Proper operational conditions also mean increased safety.


High-quality materials and features

Then, you should take a look at the materials they are made out of. The baking pan should be very durable and also removable – so you won’t struggle when taking your precious baked goods out of the oven. Additionally, make sure that the inside of the oven is coated accordingly and with proper heat-resistant materials.

In terms of features, you should pick the one that has removable trays and different rack positions, so you can place the food exactly where it needs to be in order to achieve adequate baking. You could also choose one that has a removable crumb tray, just to make the oven’s cleaning easier for you.


3 Best Toaster Ovens for Baking (Updated Reviews) in 2021


Below you’ll find some of the top rated toaster ovens for baking out there. They have gained the highest review scores based on their performance, functionality, features, and, of course, the baked goods that come out on their tray at the end of a baking cycle. Therefore, the following products are a feasible choice when it comes to quality, durability, and results.


1. Hamilton Beach 31126 Toaster Oven Convection Oven


This one is quite a cheap toaster oven for baking and you might even find it for sale. And since it is the top pick of this selction, let’s see how it performs and what it has to offer to fulfill your baking dreams.

Probably the best feature of this toaster oven is the roll-top door. Because of it, you can easily access the countertop and your baked goods without having to fear that you’ll spill anything on it. It is completely out of reach once it’s fully opened and then you can easily remove the baking pan or the crumb tray.

Because of its size, of only 9.41 x 18.74 x 15.24 inches, this toaster oven from Hamilton Beach is a great countertop oven, taking little space and not standing in the way of your other kitchenware.

Even though it comes with only three settings, bake, toast, and broil, you can do many things besides baking with it.

Of course, you’ll have to experience and learn the best position to place your food in, so that you’ll be able to achieve the results you want. But the two rack positions and the fact that it is a convection toaster oven will make sure that every food you might place in it will get evenly cooked or baked – just the way you want it.


Buy from for ($84.33)




2. Black&Decker TO3250XSB 8 Slice Extra Wide Convection


The toaster oven from Black+Decker comes in a wide design, being able to accommodate even the baking pans you might have at home – that means a standard pan of 9 x 13 inches. The wide interior, of 16.5 x 12.5 x 9.5 inches, can accommodate a 12-inch pizza, or up to eight slices of toast.

It uses the convection technology to keep things baking at an equal temperature throughout the oven. Because of the powerful heating elements within it, the temperature you will be setting on the oven’s display will actually be lower inside the oven – however, you don’t have to worry about anything as the elements will heat up in such a way that will provide the perfect baking conditions for your food.

This toaster oven also has included a removable crumb tray – which is always nice to have in such a product -, but also a pan for baking and broiling too, so that you won’t have to search for any other extra pans while you’re shopping for kitchenware.

It is a good alternative to some other products on this list because it offers the essential functions you need when baking – toast, bake, broil, convection bake – and also because it’s quite wide and, therefore, you can bake in it almost anything you’d like.


Buy from for ($68.83)




3. Oster TSSTTVMNDG-SHP-2 Toaster Oven Digital Convection Oven


This toaster oven is a great alternative if, let’s say, you have a bigger family or you just want to be prepared in case you have some guests and want to show them your baking skills. Because of its large dimensions, of 19.72 W x 16.29 D x 11.33 H inches, this oven could be easily used as a toaster pizza oven – as it can fit a 12-inch pizza without any problems.

The temperature it can bake at, which is between 150 and 450 degrees F will make you feel like there’s no difference between this toaster oven and the normal, traditional oven. The temperature can be adjusted as you wish, so you can be in full control of the outcome of your baked goods.

It has two rack positions available and it can fit up to six slices of toast – which, again, makes it a large capacity oven, but it still can be used on the countertop; just make sure it has all the space it needs around it so that the operating conditions will be properly met.

The entire baking process can be done via the digital control panel which is very intuitive, and it requires only the press of a couple of buttons before the toaster oven will start baking.


Buy from for ($91.11)
 Protection Status