Sandwich makers – Jen’s Buying Guide & Comparison


If you’re here just to find the best sandwich maker, Grandma Jen recommends the Hamilton Beach 25460A as it offers the best performance at a fair price. No matter what kind of sandwiches and what thickness you prefer your slices of bread to have, you will find this sandwich maker really handy, due to its floating lid. The cooking grids are completely non-stick, so you do not risk burning your food, and cleaning is also a breeze. You only need a damp cloth and you will be able to make the sandwich maker look as good as new after each use. The upright storage option saves up quite a bit of space, so you can keep it on your kitchen counter. If you can’t find the Hamilton Beach 25460A in stock, your next best option should be the Hamilton Beach 25490A as it is a reliable model that should help you with your kitchen work.



Products worth your attention:


The Good
The Bad



Sandwiches are considered quite a staple type of food in many countries, because they are easy to make and they can be well balanced in terms of introducing all the important categories of nutrients in one’s diet. A sandwich maker can turn the process of making sandwiches in a fun experience, and it also makes them tastier, which is a great plus for many. Sandwiches can be served during any meal of the day, be it breakfast, lunch or dinner, so, with the help of a simple device like this, you can have yourself covered in case you are busy and you do not have enough time to cook at your disposal. If you go shopping for a sandwich maker, keep the following aspects in mind.


Top Features – An overview




It is always a good recommendation to get the right size of a kitchen appliance that will serve you and your needs. For instance, a small sandwich maker that only makes two sandwiches may be a good idea for someone living alone, or for a young couple. However, if your family is more numerous, you should consider getting a larger sandwich maker that can create tasty sandwiches for everyone at the same time. Do not forget that larger models are usually more expensive, and you should spend money on them, only if you really need that size.


Cooking surface

It is not unusual for sandwich makers that are very cheap to have the cooking surface made of cast iron. While cast iron is, generally speaking, a good idea as cooking surface, your sandwiches may get stuck to it, and the result will not be a very palatable one. If you read the breakfast sandwich maker reviews written by consumers and published online, you will notice that the most popular models are those that come equipped with nonstick cooking surface. Your sandwiches will always turn up great and ready to eat, and you will not have to scrap the remains from the surface.



Simple operation

Sandwich makers are, usually, very simple to operate. You only need to create your sandwich, making sure that the slices of bread do not stick out of the cooking surface, and then press the lid and wait for your sandwich to get cooked. A good and reliable sandwich maker takes only a few minutes to turn your great sandwiches into really amazing ones.


Easy to clean

Let’s not forget that using kitchen appliances usually means that you will have to deal with grease, food spills and food stains. When it comes to sandwich makers, your best bet is to go with a model that is easy to clean. If the cooking surface is made of some kind of nonstick surface, you will notice right away that it is also easy to wipe clean without any effort. There are models that can be dissembled and washed in your dishwasher and they are considered the most convenient by buyers.


Saving space

The best sandwich maker for your needs should be one capable of saving some space in your kitchen. A light model will never take up too much room in your pantry or on your kitchen counter, so you may want to take this into consideration before purchasing one for your household. Some models can be stored in an upright position, so they can end up taking up even less room. However, you should never sacrifice performance for such details.



The type of handle used for lifting the lid from the sandwich maker should be made of a tough material. If you see a model with the handle made of plastic, do not expect it to last for too long. No matter how hardened the plastic used for the handle is, in due time, due to exposure to heat, even if not directly, the handle will break and you will no longer be able to use the entire sandwich maker. Preferably, the handle should be made of steel or stainless steel.



Do not forget to look for any additional extras provided with your purchase, if you want to get the best sandwich maker for your needs. A drip tray, for instance, can greatly improve your cooking experience, because it will catch all the grease that will flow from the meat used in your sandwiches. Washing the drip tray is easier than trying to scoop all the greasy spills from the bottom of the sandwich maker.

Adjustable temperature controls come in handy when you want to really be in charge of how your sandwiches will be cooked. Some recipes are often provided when purchasing a sandwich maker, so you can have a good starting point for your new and improved breakfasts from now on.



There is usually a strong correlation between the size of the sandwich maker you intend to purchase and its pricing. However, be aware that most sandwich makers that come equipped with additional functions, such as cooking eggs, burgers, and so on, tend to be more on the expensive side. Brand models are also known to be a bit more expensive, compared to no name models, but they are still affordable, while providing their users with great results and outstanding innovations in kitchen appliances.



5 Best Sandwich Makers (Reviews) in 2020



1. Hamilton Beach Electric Panini Press Grill With Locking Lid


3.Hamilton Beach 25460AEasily capable of grilling sandwiches of varying thickness, the Hamilton Beach 25460A Panini Press Gourmet Sandwich Maker lets you use the freshest ingredients so you can enjoy mouthwatering sandwiches done your way in your own time.

This awesome sandwich maker has a cafe-style floating lid that presses any size sandwich evenly, so the food comes out nice and not squished to an ugly gooey mess. The 10-inch by 8-inch nonstick grids can accommodate a pair of large sandwiches or up to three sandwiches simultaneously, saving you time, effort and electricity. With this machine in your kitchen, you won’t have to go through the hassle of drive thru ordering, waiting and queueing, since you can make your own sandwiches in the comfort of the home.

The appliance has power and preheat lights to provide easy control and effortless use. Craving for a delectable panini for lunch? The Hamilton Beach 25460A has that covered as well. Enjoy restaurant-level results at a fraction of the cost and at any time of the day.

This kitchen appliance is equipped with power and preheat lights so you know it is switched on and ready for cooking. Prepare a sandwich as thin as a basic grilled cheese to as thick as a full Reuben sandwich. How thin or thick your sandwich goes is all up to you. The cooked sandwich is easy to retrieve from the non-stick grid. You can heat panini sandwiches with ease and in only minutes right in your own home.

The lock hinge allows you to work on Bruschetta, pizza and quesadillas without ruining the appearance of the food items.



Buy from for ($24.56)





2. Hamilton Beach Dual Breakfast Sandwich Maker with Timer


2.Hamilton Beach 25490AAble to make 1 to 2 sandwiches, the Hamilton Beach 25490A Dual Breakfast Sandwich Maker is ready to cook your sandwiches in five minutes. With this machine, you can cook delicious breakfast sandwiches without the costs of ordering through drive thru.

It allows you to choose your favorite ingredients to make your sandwiches, including processed meats, precooked meats, cheese, eggs and much more. With this device, you can make a pair of breakfast sandwiches perfectly to your desire. The built-in digital timer lets you know the food is ready with an audible tone. This model allows you to enjoy a pair of beautifully assembled sandwiches in five minutes or less.

The Hamilton Beach 25490A Dual Breakfast Sandwich Maker is easy to use. It allows you to create your own healthy breakfast alternatives so you can cut down on the processed food you take in. You can use low fat cheese, whole-grain English muffins, egg whites, lean meat, your choice of vegetables and more. The unit ships with quick and easy recipes that can help you prepare delectable, mouth-watering sandwiches. Thanks to the removable dishwasher-friendly components, the unit is easy to clean.

With this machine, you can easily make sandwiches. Just spray some fat or oil to the plates and rings and preheat. The bread goes into the lower ring, and it can be topped with pre- cooked meat, cheese or vegetables. The top ring and plate are then lowered into place. Then one large egg with the yolk broken can be set atop the bread. After that, simply close the lid and set the timer. Everything is so easy with this dual breakfast sandwich maker!



Buy from for ($38.92)





3. Cuisinart 5-in-1 Griddler GR-4N Silver


1.Cuisinart GR-4NThe Cuisinart GR-4N 5-in-1 Griddler is a versatile multi-function model that can serve as a panini press, contact grill, full griddle, half grill/half griddle and a full grill. Big in features, this compact appliance can be used to cook steak, poultry, burgers, veggies and fish as a full grill. With the cover lying flat, the appliance creates twice the cooking surface.

This functionality makes full use of the unit and also offers versatility. When used as a full griddler, the Cuisinart GR-4N is a great device to cook eggs, pancakes, hash browns, French toast and breakfast meats, perfect for making breakfast for two or even for a large family. The griddle side of the plates offers a pretty large surface area on which a variety of foods can be cooked simultaneously to reduce waiting times.

The half grill/half griddle functionality helps you create full meals including bacon and eggs or potatoes and steak simultaneously. Just have the unit in the flat position then place one of the plates with the grill side facing up and the other plate with the griddle side facing up. In this position, both the griddle temperature selector and the grill/panini temperature selector can be used.

As a panini press, the appliance can grill quesadillas, breads and sandwiches. The bread gets toasted and the sandwich warmed nicely with the two grill or griddle plates pressing the sandwich between. For the best tasting panini, it is best to use freshly baked bread.

As a contact grill, the unit can cook boneless meat pieces, burgers and thin slices of veggies and meat.



Buy from for ($74.99)





4. Hamilton Beach 25475A Breakfast Sandwich Maker


4.Hamilton Beach 25475AEnabling you to maximize the healthiest breakfast options, the Hamilton Beach 25475A Breakfast Sandwich Maker lets you prepare your own sandwiches your way. Use only the freshest and healthiest ingredients you want in your sandwich, so you can use organic veggies, whole wheat breads, preservative-free precooked meats or lean meats, organic eggs and fat-free cheese when you want to.

This is the perfect food cooking machine for dieters who need to cut down on calories from fats, carbohydrates and cholesterol-laden preserved food. This sandwich maker can help you enjoy a protein-filled and satisfying meal. It enables you to prepare two different sandwiches at once, each customized to your preference for greater variety in what you take in.

The Hamilton Beach 25475A Breakfast Sandwich Maker can be used any time of the day, so you can have healthy sandwiches not just in the morning but for lunch and dinner as well. You can also use a pancake as the bread and then pour syrup onto your cooked sandwich.The machine is ready in five minutes so you won’t have to wait too long to preheat the grill plates. It allows you to use any bread type or thickness you love, including small bagels, biscuits and English muffins. All the removable parts on this piece of kitchen equipment are dishwasher-safe. The cooking surfaces are equipped with a durable, non-stick coating that makes cooking easy and sandwich removal problem-free.

The appliance ships with quick and easy recipes that help you prepare a variety of sandwiches so you can augment your own recipes with more new ones.



Buy from for ($24.99)





5. Imusa USA GAU 80102 Large Electric Panini Press


5.IMUSA GAU-80102Shipped to you in a lovely gift box to make an awesome present for any occasion, the IMUSA, GAU-80102, Electric Panini and Sandwich Maker features a stainless steel exterior that makes it a terrific addition to any kitchen countertop. The stainless steel finish also ensures protection from corrosion and chipping for long-term use and durability.

This is a great piece of kitchen equipment that is easy to use any time of the day. It has a safety latch to keep curious little hands from getting caught between the grill plates. This electric panini maker lets you put in your choice of ingredients into any sandwich, so you can have a range of options, especially healthy ones, to make your own sandwich meals.

The sandwich maker offers an adjustable height with its spring-loaded hinge so you can cook any size or thickness sandwich. Go as high or as thin as you like in your sandwich preparations. The unit is easy to use. Just plug it into an AC outlet, wait for it to preheat, then place the sandwich or bread between the plates. You won’t have to press down to ensure even cooking, which also helps you enjoy lovely-looking cooked sandwiches that are not squished beyond recognition after they are done.

The Power On and Heat-ready indicator lights let you know when the machine is ready to cook your food. The Panini press lets you prepare terrific paninis just like what you can order from a restaurant or drive thru.

With this convenient machine, you can grill veggies, sandwiches, meats, pork chops and a whole lot more food items for versatility in your meal options.



Buy from for ($49.39)





Benefits of owning your own sandwich maker


Eating a sandwich or two in the morning for breakfast is a good choice, because you can pack all the important nutritional food groups in a single dish that does not require a lot of preparation. You can always opt for the sandwiches offered by fast food places, but the truth is these are loaded with sauces, salt and sugar that just add to the final calorie count, without offering you better nutrition. If you want to maintain the quality of your sandwiches high, as well as their nutritional value, you will need to make your own sandwiches at home.

If you want to make your food extra tasty, pick a sandwich maker and put together a few sandwiches every morning, enjoying the great taste of toast and of a warm meal. There are plenty of websites on the Internet offering you the best sandwich maker recipes, so you do not have to worry that you might run out of ideas. A lot of benefits are involved with making your own sandwiches and they should not be overlooked.

The best toasted sandwich maker reviews always boast about the important health benefits involved with cooking your own meals and even sandwiches and we have no reason to skip them over. The truth is that when you are buying a sandwich from the drive through or a fast food restaurant, you cannot know all the ingredients they use. The meat they use may be loaded with salt, and there is no mystery in this day and age that the sauces used for seasoning sandwiches, burgers and the like are extremely rich in sugar. All these ingredients go straight to your waistline, not to mention all the preservatives and additives that can affect your digestive system on the long run. If you get a sandwich maker, you will be able to choose your ingredients and even make tastier alternatives to what you normally see sold straight over the counter. So, if you don’t have any ideas, you can just pick the best sandwich recipes to make at home from the Internet and start making delicious sandwiches, without having to stop at the drive through on your way to work.

Let’s not forget you will also be able to save some money while making sandwiches at home. Get a sandwich maker or a grill press and start making your own, without even having to spend extra for a type of dish that is easy and fun to make.



How to use a sandwich maker


Using a sandwich maker is extremely easy. There are plenty of models on the market, and while some may come with extra features, they all have a pretty straightforward mode of operation. So, what you need to do is to grab the recipe for the best sandwich to make at home that sounds like something you would like, gather all the ingredients, and prepare for making your first sandwiches with the help of a sandwich maker.

Most units on the market need to be preheated before you go to actually assembling the sandwich and letting it cook. The entire process is very simple, and manufacturers provide accurate step by step instructions so you can begin making delicious sandwiches free of all the additives and preservatives those made by fast food restaurants are usually loaded with. So, the first step is to turn on the machine and let it heat up for several minutes. This is an important step because your sandwiches will be ready much faster if you are preparing the machine in this manner. On the models competing for the title of the best sandwich maker in 2020, you will notice a power light that lets you know that the unit is on, and also a preheat light that basically tells you when the machine is ready to use.

Now, prepare the first slice of bread. If you want to enhance the taste of your sandwich, a good idea would be to coat one side of the slice with a bit of butter. As the bread is toasted, the butter will add an unmistakable flavor that will make your sandwiches much more palatable than the ones served in restaurants. After you are done, place the slice of bread inside the slot or on the cooking area, depending on how your sandwich maker looks like, and then add all the rest of the ingredients layer after layer. Good options include a thin layer of cheese and some meat of your choosing, as well as some sliced tomatoes or a small leaf of lettuce. Cover everything with another slice of bread, then lower the lid over and press as indicated in the manual. Some units come equipped with a timer that will let you know when your sandwich is ready. After that, you just need to place your sandwich on a plate and enjoy its great taste.

There are all kinds of models on the market, so you can choose the one you like. For instance, the best sandwich maker and griller will help you put together all kinds of meals, since it will be able to grill burgers and steaks, besides making sandwiches. Such options are more than welcome for someone looking to eat healthier, but without spending a lot of time in the kitchen.



Types of sandwich makers we have reviewed with the help of Grandma Jen



Best egg sandwich maker


1-best-egg-sandwich-makerThe best sandwich recipes for sandwich maker are the ones that include egg in them, or at least that is what the vast majority of the people living on this planet think and we tend to agree with them.

So, we decided to help you get a good and reliable sandwich maker that is capable of making eggs at the same time.

Eggs have high nutritional value and they offer you all you need for starting your day on the right foot. They are also very tasty and in combination with a regular sandwich, they create a complete meal that will keep you fueled and well prepared for the entire day.

All the models we included in our selection are very popular with breakfast eaters everywhere and they enjoy a lot of positive feedback.

They are designed by reputable manufacturers with years of experience in making sandwich makers and they are equipped with all the needed features. Putting together a highly nutritious breakfast has never been easier, and once you start using one of these great sandwich makers, you will never want to go back to buying regular sandwiches from any fast food place that happen in your way.





Best Panini sandwich maker


2-best-panini-sandwich-makerIf you are not one to be crazy about sandwiches made with sliced bread and you prefer a Panini sandwich instead, we have you covered.

You will find here the best Panini press sandwich maker models currently available on the market, and we are going to explain why they are the most appreciated.

For Panini sandwiches you need different kinds of breads, like baguettes, ciabattas or michettas. What all these breads have in common is that they are thicker than regular slices of bread, even when cut for sandwiches. That means that making Panini sandwiches requires the use of a special type of sandwich maker that can accommodate their thickness.

Usually, a floating lid is what makes these models stand out. They are also equipped with grids for grilling and they can make your sandwiches crispy and delicious. So what you will be looking for will be the best sandwich grill press that can accommodate the larger size of Panini sandwiches. We are here to help you and supply you with all the needed information on the most popular models people are happy to purchase right now. You will save time and money by using our buying guide and our recommendations.





Best breakfast sandwich maker


3-best-breakfast-sandwich-makerThe best sandwich maker for putting together a nutritious meal is the one that can help you cook your meals fast and easy. We chose the best models around with your convenience in mind, as well as by evaluating the features and the additional benefits they provide.

This is how we discovered the best sandwich toaster and grill models currently available, capable of offering you a complete breakfast solution and we want to share our findings with you. The models we selected are all very efficient for cooking breakfast and offering you the best sandwiches you can make at home.

Since breakfast is the most important meal of the day, it is very important to get the right unit for your needs. Some can toast your bread to perfection, while others come equipped with a grill on which you can make other dishes besides sandwiches.

With so many options at your disposal, choosing can be hard, which is why we decided to offer you the most important information on the best models currently on the market, so you can take your pick fast and easy. No matter which one you will choose, you will find it a great choice for cooking breakfast every day.





Popular brands


Sandwich makers are very popular, so it is nothing unusual to see them in almost every home. Certain brands are known for being favored by consumers because of their overall great performance. Here are the names you should look up when searching for a good sandwich maker.



Hamilton Beach – offering a blend of commercial products and household oriented appliances for improving daily living, Hamilton Beach is known for making some really great sandwich makers, as well. Their friendly customer support recommends them along with the high quality of their products.



Cuisinart – considered by many to be a complete culinary resource when it comes to kitchen appliances, Cuisinart is the brand name you will equally find in homes and restaurant kitchens.



T-fal – geared towards making people’s lives easier, T-fal is renowned for their innovations, especially in the field of creating nonstick surfaces for convenient cooking.


1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (7 votes, average: 5.00 out of 5)
Loading... Protection Status