The Essential Guide to Finding the Best Popover Pan + Reviews
To bake the perfect popovers you need the best popover pan and in this short paragraph, you can find the right product especially if you have little time on your hands to prospect the market. After a careful analysis of the value and quality offered by the critically acclaimed models available for sale, we have concluded that the option you should get is the Bellemain 6 Cup Nonstick Popover Pan. It has a nonstick finish to let the popovers slide right off once they are done for effortless baking. The cups are 2.25” deep and have a diameter of 3” to let your baked goods rise properly and it helps the baked batter get that specific hollow texture. The pan is made from durable, welded metal and it is dishwasher safe. In the event that our first pick is no longer available, we recommend you take the time to consider the Chicago Metallic Professional 12-Cup Mini-Popover Pan.
Our Top Choice
This pan has a very effective nonstick surface that saves you from having to grease it with unhealthy amounts of oil. The cups are separated with enough space to let air circulate around them which will promote even baking and it will allow the popovers to rise.
It’s good for small families but the 6 cups can be insufficient if you need to bake larger batches frequently.
If you’ve tried to get the perfect popovers but you can never get them to rise properly, this pan combines performance, quality, and ease of use so that even an inexperienced baker can get impressive results.
This model is made from heavy-duty aluminized steel that offers superior heat conduction for even baking. It is perfect for large families since you can bake a dozen popovers at a time. It can also be used to prepare muffins, cornbread, and Yorkshire puddings.
The unit is advertised as dishwasher safe, but it is best to wash it by hand since the weld points are prone to rust.
This is a great option if you are looking for a product that can be used to prepare multiple baked goods, not just popovers. It is very easy to use and it has a non-stick coating for effortless baking and easy cleanup.
The heavy cast aluminum construction helps this model provide quicker and even heating. It has a nonstick coating for easy food release and cleanup. It is also fitted with two handles at the sides so that you can move the pan safely in and out of the oven.
The vertical walls of the pan are quite deep and this makes it a bit difficult to get popovers that expand properly in the cups.
You can’t go wrong with a Nordic Ware product since the brand is known for its high-quality bakeware. With this beginner-friendly pan, you can prepare delicious popovers that are airy inside and crispy outside.
10 Best Popover Pans (Updated Reviews) in 2020
We want to help you get a good popover pan, which is why we have listed the critically acclaimed products we found after our research and showcased them below. The products you’ll find here are guaranteed to satisfy most needs so do take a quick look below if you have the time.
- 1. Bellemain 6 Cup Nonstick Popover Pan
- 2. Chicago Metallic Professional 12 Cup Mini Popover Pan
- 3. Nordic Ware Grand Popover Pan
- 4. USA Pans 6 Well Popover Pan
- 5. ChefMade Muffin 6 Cavity Cake Pan
- 6. Chicago Metallic Professional 6 Cup Popover Pan
- 7. Anolon 59181 6 Cup Steel Popover Pan
- 8. Fox Run 4756 Linking Mini Popover Pan
- 9. HostStyleZ 9 Cup Popover Pan
- 10. Beasea Nonstick Popover Cake Pan
- Our Comprehensive Buying Guide
- Frequently Asked Questions
1. Bellemain 6 Cup Nonstick Popover Pan
The non stick popover pan from Belleman combines performance, quality, and ease of use so that even amateur bakers can now show off with popovers that rise the way they should and that have a mouth-watering texture. This is achieved thanks to the specially designed cups that are just deep enough to let the batter rise and stay light and tender inside.
You can also count on the rugged construction of this pan to last you for years and to give you trouble-free use. The metal is dark to help it absorb heat faster for shorter baking time and perfect results. The bottom and sides of the cups have a nonstick coating that lets the popovers slide out easily.
The nonstick finish will also make cleanup a breeze since there’ll be hardly any leftovers inside the cups. You can also put the pan straight into the dishwasher if you prefer so since the materials are dishwasher safe.
The cups are separated and there is a lot of space between them to let the air circulate which will promote even baking.
The 2.25” depth of the cups allows the batter to rise and pop for that distinctive look that these tasty baked goods are known for.
Since the pan is nonstick, it is very easy to take the popovers out of the cups once they’re baked and you’ll be able to make do without using an excessive amount of butter.
It has a welded metal construction that is guaranteed to help the product last for many years of trouble-free use.
Since the pan only has six cups, it’s not the best option for large families or for people that really like their popovers and need to bake many batches.
It is a bit expensive but since it goes on sale fairly frequently you might be able to get it cheaper.Buy from Amazon.com for ($16.45)
2. Chicago Metallic Professional 12 Cup Mini Popover Pan
If you’re looking for a mini popover pan that can bake smaller bite-sized snacks that are easier to munch on, then this is a good option to consider especially since its versatile design allows for multiple baking uses. This option can also be used to bake traditional muffins, Yorkshire puddings, and cornbread.
Each cup has the standard 2.25” depth to let the popover rise but it has a smaller diameter of 2”. Since the pan has 12 cups this makes it possible to bake for yourself and your family but also for parties where you need more snacks to satisfy a large crowd.
You can also cook quicker with this option since it is made from aluminized steel with a dark color that helps promote superior heat conduction and even baking. What’s more, the cups are treated with silicone to make it nonstick and hence easier to clean since the batter won’t stick to the walls of the cups.
It is a versatile option that lets you bake more than just popovers and this way customers will get more value out of it.
You can trust the quality that this product offers not only because it is made by a reputable brand but also because it has garnered hundreds of positive customer reviews.
The pan is made from aluminized steel which is a premium material that is very durable and that has higher heat conductivity for more even baking.
You can use it to bake for parties or friend gatherings since this model has 12 cups.
It is coated with silicone which gives it a nonstick quality for easy baking and cleaning.
It’s best to stick to hand washing if possible since the weld points can start to rust if you leave the pan in the dishwasher for too long.
The rails make it quite difficult to move the pan in and out of the oven.Buy from Amazon.com for ($26.9)
3. Nordic Ware Grand Popover Pan
The Nordic Ware popover pan lets you make six large popovers at a time faster than you would have thought possible thanks to the premium cast aluminum construction that offers superior baking performance and durability. Hence, the product is guaranteed to last you for years. The exterior is heat reflective and that lets the batter brown uniformly to enhance the texture and taste of food.
You can also use this pan to bake over-sized muffins, Yorkshire pudding, crown muffins or any of your other favorite molded desserts. The two vents in the center will let the hot air in the oven surround each cup for even cooking so that all your baked goods look and taste the same.
This model is also available in a petite style which is perfect for making bite-sized snacks for parties or for some quality tea time with your family. No matter which option you prefer, they all share the same quality and reliability that has made Nordic Ware one of the top brands of bakeware.
It is equipped with handles that are very comfortable to use and that let you move the pan in and out of the oven without fear that it will slip out of your hands.
The pan is designed to maximize airflow and make your popovers rise higher and have an airy inside thanks to the use of premium materials and the vents in the center.
It has a nonstick coating that lets the food release effortlessly out of the cups and into your plate and it makes hand washing the item quicker.
It is available in different styles and if you need to make small bite-sized baked snacks, you have the option of getting the petite model.
Quality comes at a price and you need to be ready to pay extra if you want to get this Nordic Ware product.
While the pan is nonstick at first, it does tend to lose this quality with use and you’ll need to start applying more grease.Buy from Amazon.com for ($24.74)
4. USA Pans 6 Well Popover Pan
This model is made in the USA from heavy-gauge aluminized steel that helps confer it a sturdy construction and it features a unique fluted design that enhances the nonstick properties of the cups. The material also gives the unit extra strength and warp resistance. The pan offers ideal heating distribution and increased airflow so that your popovers are baked evenly.
One feature that really makes this product stand out from the rest comes from its Americoat finish which is a premium food-grade silicone coating that will make it very easy to take your baked items out of the pan without damaging the crust. What’s more, Americoat is also free of harmful chemicals so that you can be sure that the pan is safe for the entire family.
The silicone coating is also very durable and it will help with cleaning especially since the manufacturer does not recommend washing it in the dishwasher.
If you care about the environment then you will be happy to learn that 65% of the steel used in the manufacturing of this product is recycled.
It has round borders around the edges that can be used like handles to hold the pan safely when you take it out of the oven.
The unique fluted design is engineered to maximize the nonstick properties of the pan and add extra strength and protection against dents and warps.
The product is made in the USA and it offers excellent performance since it can be used for both home but also for commercial heavy-duty purposes.
The unit cannot be washed in the dishwasher but this isn’t a big problem since the nonstick surface makes cleaning the pan by hand feel effortless.
You can’t use the pan in temperatures above 400 degrees Fahrenheit and there are some recipes that require baking in temperatures higher than that.Buy from Amazon.com for ($29.99)
5. ChefMade Muffin 6 Cavity Cake Pan
If you’re looking for an affordable popover pan that can be used to bake other items as well, then this 6-cup pan will make a good addition to your kitchen. It is FDA approved and it uses food-grade silicone coating instead of Teflon and this material will ensure that no harmful substances will be released when baking at high temperatures.
The pan is made from 0.8mm carbon steel that is designed to accelerate heating and ensure it’s even and since the material heats up faster this will help you save time when baking. Furthermore, the edges are strengthened to avoid warping and to make it more convenient for the user to grab the pan tightly without the risk of it slipping.
This is a highly versatile product that you can use to bake almost everything for your breakfast, lunch, and dinner, and you can also experiment with new ways of preparing your favorite foods, including popovers.
This model is less likely to warp in high temperatures since the edges are strengthened and that adds more traction and stability to the pan since it feels thicker to the hand.
The superior nonstick surface has high-temperature resistance and you can use less oil when cooking without worrying about the food sticking to the walls of the pan.
The use of high-quality carbon steel as the primary materials allows for fast heating for less cooking time and lower energy consumption.
This model is available in different sizes if you need more cups or if you want to prepare bite-sized snacks.
The cups are not deep enough to create that classic popover look and they are a bit wide but you can still cook delicious popovers that have the signature taste and hollow texture.
While the silicone coating can handle high temperatures, you need to use soft utensils since it can scrape off.Buy from Amazon.com for ($18.99)
6. Chicago Metallic Professional 6 Cup Popover Pan
If you’re looking for a large popover pan that can also be used for baking Yorkshire puddings and classic muffins, then this versatile product is well worth your attention. Unlike some of the other similar products that Chicago Metallic offers this one has a heavier metal construction and armor-glide coating for an easier release.
It comes fitted with 6 cups that are appropriately spaced out and deep enough to let you prepare popovers that your family and guests will love. The special metal construction allows the batter to be airy and evenly baked. You can also cook with less oil or butter since the special coating makes the pan nonstick and hence very easy to clean as well.
Another thing that makes this model special is the overwhelmingly positive customer feedback that it has received. Buyers are very pleased with it since it makes preparing mouth-watering baked goods feel easy even for beginners.
It has a durable metal construction and the coating can handle high temperatures of up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit without peeling off.
Since this product comes from a reputable brand, you can be certain that you’re purchasing a high-quality option that won’t disappoint.
It is a versatile product that you can also use to bake other items as well such as Yorkshire puddings, muffins, and even cornbread.
It has a wire rack design that allows for excellent air circulation so that your items bake evenly.
The cups are deep to let the popover rise to the top and that makes it easier even for amateur cooks to accomplish every recipe.
It is a bit difficult to grip when you need to put it in the oven or take it out since the wires that hold the cups together are not that comfortable to grab onto.
It is quite expensive for a pan that only has 6 cups.Buy from Amazon.com for ($26.15)
7. Anolon 59181 6 Cup Steel Popover Pan
With this model, everyone can surprise their guests or family with a freshly-baked treat since the pan is designed to be easy to use and provide reliable results and hold up to the standards of even the most exigent home bakers. The steel construction allows the pan to maximize heat distribution for consistent baking with each batch.
The durable carbon steel is also sturdy enough to resist bending and warping in the oven since it can safely handle temperatures of up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit. While you do get only 6 cups, this model can still be used for parties or other events where there’s a large gathering of people since baking one batch takes less time compared to other products.
As expected from a high-quality model, the pan comes with a premium nonstick coating both inside and out to deliver easy food release. This feature also makes the unit very easy to clean.
The frame of the pan allows plenty of space for you to comfortably hold it even when using bulky oven mitts and the open-frame construction also helps improve airflow so that each popover bakes evenly.
It has a non-stick interior and exterior to ensure that whatever you’re baking won’t stick to the walls of the cups and this feature will also promote popover browning.
Thanks to its heavy-duty carbon steel construction, this option can handle warping since it is rated to handle temperatures as high as 450 degrees Fahrenheit.
The product is also rust- and corrosion-resistant which means that it is guaranteed to last for a very long time.
You can’t wash it in the dishwasher but since it is made from non stick materials, cleaning it by hand doesn’t take very long.
You need to be careful not to drop the pan since the welding that keeps the cups together isn’t as durable as it looks.Buy from Amazon.com for ($24.07)
8. Fox Run 4756 Linking Mini Popover Pan
If you’re looking to entertain guests or if your family really likes mini bite-sized popovers, then Fox Run has an excellent product for you. The pan has a carbon steel construction that is much more durable than a silicone popover pan which tends to be the go-to choice for many when baking mini popovers.
The 12 cups that this pan comes fitted with are deep and tapered and that will let the popovers turn out moist and airy with crispy golden domes. This option can also handle hot ovens thanks to its carbon steel construction, so there is no risk in using it in a high heat oven especially since a hot oven is required to get a crispy, puffy and golden brown popover.
Furthermore, since the same model is available in different sizes and cup configurations that share the same quality construction and ease of use, you can get a Fox Run product for every need.
The cups are spaced far apart from one another so that each one gets an equal amount of heat which allows for consistent baking so that once you take the pan out of the oven, each popover will be baked evenly.
The nonstick finish makes it very easy to take the baked goods out of the cups without them sticking to the walls and it also facilitates cleaning.
The heavy-duty construction features the use of strong gauge steel as the primary material for long and reliable use.
It is a versatile product since you can also use it to prepare muffins, Yorkshire puddings, cornbread and more.
The nonstick coating is very good but it doesn’t last forever and if you bake very often it might be worth it to get a more expensive model with a better coating.
You need to be careful when cleaning it since the edges of some cups are a bit sharp.Buy from Amazon.com for ($17.99)
9. HostStyleZ 9 Cup Popover Pan
This is another versatile option that you should get if you want to bake more items since the cups in this pan have the perfect size and shape for making popovers, cakes, pudding, bread, and other desserts. It is made of food-grade heavy-gauge carbon steel and the cups have a nonstick coating for easy release and cleaning.
The pan can handle the high temperatures in the oven and you can also use it to prepare cold desserts such as jellies since the pan can also be used in the refrigerator. This is a great family product since the 9 round cups are large enough to let you bake enough for the entire family.
Once you are done baking, cleaning the product is as easy as it can be and you can even bring the children to help you out since the process is quite fun and the nonstick coating ensures that batter won’t stick or burn to the walls of the cups.
One of the main advantages of this model is its versatility since you can use the pan to bake almost anything you may want from popovers and bread to pudding and jelly.
It features a linking design that lets the air circulate more efficiently and this way the dome of the popover will puff up and rise higher to create that perfect crispy texture.
The heavy-duty construction allows this model to handle harsh temperature conditions of up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit and it can also be used in the refrigerator.
It is suitable for large families since you can prepare anything that your kids might want using a single pan.
The material used by the manufacturer is great but it demands extra care and you can’t wash it in the dishwasher since if moisturized for too long it will begin to corrode.
It is difficult to grab the edges, especially when wearing large oven mitts.Buy from Amazon.com for ($17.99)
10. Beasea Nonstick Popover Cake Pan
If you’re looking for a cheap popover pan that offers a lot of value for the money, the Beasea alternative is a good choice to consider especially since it can also be used to prepare a multitude of other baked goods. It is made from carbon steel material that is very durable and heats up evenly so that your recipes end up looking beautiful and tasting delicious.
This pan is designed to give you superior results for a low price and this is helped by its design since the cups are spaced evenly from one another so that there is enough space for the heat to surround them from every side.
It has 9 cups with three different styles to help you prepare interesting desserts and other delicacies. Furthermore, this option is excellent for daily cooking but it can also be used for special occasions such as friend gatherings, parties, family dinners and more.
The premium quality carbon steel material is heat resistant to let you prepare delicacies that require higher oven temperatures and it is non-toxic so that you can bake for the entire family.
It is a perfect choice for all occasions thanks to its versatile design that allows you to bake not only popovers but also muffins, puddings, banquet desserts and more.
The 9 baking cups come in 3 different shapes and will let you prepare food for large gatherings especially since baking time is faster with this nifty model.
If you’re prospecting the market for an affordable and versatile baking pan then you’ll find it difficult to select a more suitable choice than this one.
It is not very deep and it uses a design that is more akin to a muffin pan which means that while you can still make popovers, they won’t rise as much.
It is not dishwasher safe and you’ll need to wash it by hand.Buy from Amazon.com for ($14.99)
Our Comprehensive Buying Guide
There are many popover pans on the market for you to choose, each one with unique features which make it difficult to decide on just one product. Making the right decision requires some thorough research on the many features that this product has. This is why you can’t always rely on just one popover pan review to tell you everything that you need to know about the product.
Therefore, to make things just a bit easier for you, we have gathered some information that will guide you regarding purchasing the right product. Take a quick look below to see more.
How many cups do you need?
Aside from the design of the pan, the easiest way to differentiate between different products is to take a quick look at the number of cups. When choosing the ideal number of cups no one can guide you since the choice depends on the size of your family or the way that you intend to use the pan.
There is a huge variety of options available on the market as far as the size of the pan is concerned but most of the models are usually available in 6-cup quantity. This size is best if you have a small family and you don’t need to bake a lot of items.
However, if you do have a large family or if you want to use the popover pans for events where you need to entertain a large crowd of people then it is best to buy a product that comes with extra cups.
You can still manage with a small pan but you need to be ready to bake multiple batches which will take more time. Some people don’t mind this but others prefer spending as little time in the kitchen as possible, so in the end, the choice is all yours.
Materials and ease of cleaning
Popover pans are made from many different materials but steel and aluminum are among the most popular and practical ones to purchase. These materials conduct heat very well and they don’t rust easily, which makes them quite durable. What’s more, they are also very easy to clean which is a very important feature to consider.
Most of the units on the market come with a layer of nonstick coating material that offers two main advantages. It makes the batter not stick to the inside of the cups for an easy release and it makes cleaning a breeze.
With that said, there are some nonstick coatings that are more fragile than others and for this reason, some pans are not recommended to be washed in a dishwasher. Instead, you’ll need to stick to manual washing. After looking at numerous popover pan reviews we found that most buyers prefer having a dishwasher safe pan even if they need to pay a little more for it.
For anyone who doesn’t want to compromise on the quality of their popovers, there are many dedicated pans available on the market. However, for the average customer who prefers to get the best value for the money, there are many versatile pans that can also be used for baking muffins, cakes, puddings, and other delicacies.
This way, if you don’t want to stuff your kitchen with countless pans, you can get a single one that you can use for all the confectionery that you baked. Do keep in mind that with such pans, your popover will be smaller so if you prefer bigger popovers that rise higher, then you should settle for a popover-only pan.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What’s a popover pan and what can it be used for?
This type of pan is designed specifically for baking popovers and it has a different construction when compared to a standard muffin pan. The pan is made with taller and narrower cups and that helps achieve a distinctive shape that will create steam to help the batter expand upward and become light and hollow on the inside.
Popover pans are also made with sturdy materials that can handle higher oven temperatures since one of the secrets of making perfect popovers is to make sure that the pan is very hot before you add the butter and the batter.
This is also the reason why this type of pan usually features cups that are welded to a wire rack. The design might look odd but it helps promote air circulation and even heat around the cups. Once baked, the unique texture of the popover lets you fill them up with anything you want.
Q: What’s the best material for a popover pan?
Most popover pans are made of either aluminum or steel since these are two of the most practical and popular choices on the market. There are many manufacturers that use a combination of these two materials so that buyers can get all the benefits of both steel and aluminum in a single product.
There are also alternatives that are just as good if not better such as cast aluminum and heavy-duty steel. You can also consider getting a pan made from cast iron since for many experts this is the superior material, but the downside is that cast iron pans are not only more expensive but also very difficult to find.
You also need to consider that while cast iron may help you achieve better results, it does require extra care so if you prefer having a pan that is easy to use and clean, then aluminum or steel is better.
Q: What is the difference between a popover pan and a muffin pan?
Popover pans and muffin pans have a few significant differences between them that range from things that are easier to see such as design to things that are less obvious such as materials. For starters, to get that puffy structure at the top that popovers are known for, the pan needs to have cups with elongated walls to let the batter rise and pop.
Most popover pans also have an open-end design which promotes better airflow for more even baking. Since popovers need to be baked at higher temperatures than muffins this product also uses sturdier materials that are capable of handling higher oven temperatures.
Lastly, while you can use a muffin pan to make popovers, true popover pans are only useful for that purpose and you can’t use them to prepare muffins. Thus, the best way to differentiate a popover pan from a muffin pan is to look at the depth and shape of the cups which will be deeper and steeper.