This website is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission.

3 Best Panini Sandwich Makers – Comparison & Reviews


The Essential Guide to Finding the Best Panini Sandwich Maker + Reviews


Are you looking for the best panini sandwich maker, but you are in a hurry? Grandma Jen will let you know everything you need for a good decision in this short paragraph that will take very little of your time. The Hamilton Beach 25462Z is the model most recommended by Grandma Jen, as it offers superior performance at a very attractive price. Its floating lid allows you to accommodate larger sandwiches on the cooking grid; this is the reason why many people use it for both paninis and regular sandwiches. Because it is light and portable, it is a great solution for those who need a cooking appliance that does not take up a lot of space and can be stored away, if the need arises. The unit can be stored vertically, so it has a small footprint. If the Hamilton Beach 25462Z is out of stock, the second best solution offered by Grandma Jen is getting the Proctor Silex 25453A, which has almost the same features.



Comparison table


The Good
The Bad



Sifting through the best panini sandwich makers nowadays can make it difficult for you to make the right choice, given the immense variety of products that are available online. Luckily for you, we’ve put together a short and comprehensive guide that can assist you when it comes to selecting the right features so that you get all the benefits of a well-built option. Check it out below.


Our Comprehensive Buying Guide



Ease of use and convenience

Since most sandwich and panini aficionados are likely to get their appliances from an online retailer, sometimes it’s difficult to realize whether the model they’re prospecting is easy to use. Some of the most convenient features we’ve found in this type of product consist of a floating hinge and an adjustable thermostat. A floating hinge can mean the world for when you want to prepare bulkier sandwiches and paninis, as this way the machine will automatically adjust its height so that it offers the best results. If the thermostat is customizable, you’ll be able to eat a delicious panini in as little as two minutes or less, depending on the power of the model you will be choosing. This way, you’ll get the most of the panini maker and sandwich toaster.


Cleaning and maintenance

We all know how unpleasant it is to have an appliance that doesn’t come with removable trays because there’s no efficient way of cleaning them. Therefore, this is a somewhat necessary characteristic to look for as you’ll be able to take out the trays and even clean them using the dishwasher or with the help of warm water in the sink.


Grill surface

It goes without saying that, aside from the details we’ve already pointed out, you ought to decide between a larger or a smaller panini grill sandwich maker. It’s rather obvious that bigger is better because this way you’ll be able to feed your entire family and some friends who might be visiting. However, the larger the appliance, the more power it needs so it might be less energy efficient. Additionally, it can take up a lot of space on your countertop. You have to assess your needs and preferences before finalizing your purchase.



3 Best Panini Sandwich Makers (Updated Reviews) in 2021



The best products are showcased below. We’ve taken the time to go through some of the best panini sandwich maker reviews so that we estimate the quality and value offered for the price of these options. Ultimately, we’ve had to settle on these models as they are the most reliable, convenient, and efficient.



1. Hamilton Beach 25462Z Electric Panini Press


1.Hamilton Beach 25462ZIf you’re a student or live in an apartment where space might be a problem, perhaps you ought to check out the specs of this Hamilton Beach panini press.

It’s smaller and more lightweight than most of its competitors, and the neat thing about it is that it doesn’t cost a lot of money, given that it can usually be bought for less than thirty dollars. In addition, this appliance offers all the convenience of a floating lid, and this way you’ll be able to cook larger and smaller sandwiches and paninis.

As for the size, it may be worth noting that the dimensions of the grids are 10 inches by 8 inches. This feature gives you just enough room to prepare two sandwiches per every grilling session. Furthermore, the unit can be stored either in a cupboard or on the countertop, considering that it can be placed vertically so that it sits upright when you’re not using it.

While the Hamilton Beach model does not come with a customizable thermostat, it does have power and preheat lights that can let you know when the grids have become hot enough for you to place the sandwiches.



Perfect for students or people always on the run who want delicious sandwiches right away. The power of this sandwich maker is as big as you can get on the market for a reasonable price, meaning it will not take you more than a couple of minutes to have a deliciously tasty sandwich just the way you like it.

Its lightweight design and small dimensions make it perfect for use anytime, anywhere, even in the smallest kitchenettes or kitchens. You can even use it in your dorm room and prepare delicious snacks ready in just a few minutes.

Suitable for all sizes of sandwiches and paninis, big or small – simply place your favorite sandwich inside the device and you will enjoy an exquisite taste right away.

Extremely affordable price – purchase it online for a few bucks over $20.



Doesn’t have an automatic shut down button and you will have to unplug it after each use.


Buy from for: See the Price!





2. Proctor Silex 25453A Panini Press Gourmet


2.Proctor Silex 25453AThe Proctor Silex offers all the advantages of a well-built panini maker, given that it’s a bit larger compared to the item we have showcased above.

Moreover, it comes with the same floating lid that gives you all the freedom you may require in terms of the thickness of sandwiches you might want to prepare. The grids belonging to the Proctor Silex measure 12 inches by 8.5 inches, which means that you’ll be able to take advantage of this space and cook as many as four sandwiches at once.

As is the case with other models in the same line, this one has power and preheat lights which might come in handy for when you are looking to get perfectly cooked paninis. What’s more, the upright storage made possible by this unit is undoubtedly advantageous as it lets you utilize your countertop as you consider fit.

The versatility of the Proctor Silex cannot be denied, given that it offers more than enough room and as such, it lets owners cook quesadillas and even prepare calzone pizzas if that is what they’re after. Additionally, most of the buyer feedback we’ve gone through is favorable as buyers speak highly of how fast the sandwich maker heats up.



This amazing panini sandwich maker is everything you will ever want and wish for in this life. Its large dimensions can accommodate up to four large sandwiches or six smaller sized sandwiches at a time, meaning you can cook a delicious snack for all members of your family at once.

The floating lid allows you to adjust the thickness and crisp of your sandwiches according to your own desires.

Suitable for cooking all sorts of pita and bread-based snacks – from delicious paninis to quesadillas and even calzone pizza, according to your preferences. Last but not least, the power of this useful sandwich maker is big, allowing the device to heat up easily and cook perfect snacks anytime you use it.

Perfect for families with loads of members who require breakfast or a lightweight dinner at the same time. It can cook four large sandwiches at once meaning you will never have to wait until everything else is cooked before eating.



The rather high price. If almost all regular sandwich makers are typically sold for around $30, you will have to pay almost twice this value for this particular product.

Large dimensions – it may not fit all kitchens.


Buy from for: See the Price!





3. Oster DuraCeramic Panini Maker and Grill


If your budget is not an issue, why not have a look at the specs of the Oster DuraCeramic? After all, it is one of the most cutting-edge panini makers out there, mostly because it features ceramic cooking surfaces.

This type of material has become remarkably popular over the years, and that is mainly due to the fact that it contains no harmful substances and is nonstick. You won’t even have to go through a lot of trouble in order to clean the grids of this option, as you will be able to use a moist towel once the appliance has completely cooled down.

Since the cooking surface of the Oster DuraCeramic is so durable and safe to use, it goes without saying that you can utilize the same machine to grill some chicken and even vegetables. Fortunately, you won’t have to ruin your countertop or kitchen table because of the hot oil getting all over the place, as the appliance comes with two drip cups where the excess grease can accumulate.

A cleaning tool is part of the deal with this one. The Oster DuraCeramic is one of the most popular items in the line since it has garnered over two hundred favorable Amazon reviews.



Features ceramic cooking surfaces, an innovation in the field of serving perfect sandwiches and paninis all the time.

The ceramic surface doesn’t contain any harmful substances, and it is non-stick, meaning you will always enjoy the same crisp panini without adding dirt or debris to the device each time you make a sandwich.

Use it to grill chicken, perfect sandwiches, and even veggies all at once – this means with this product you will have the possibility of choosing between various types of delicious dishes and serve the tastiest meal every time.

Comes with two drip cups to store excess grease and oils meaning you won’t spill dirt all over the kitchen. Moreover, the product is also equipped with adjustable height wheels to be used in the comfort of your own kitchen and on any surface, no matter how low it is.



If you try to stick a sandwich inside it flies right out.


Buy from for: See the Price!