This website is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission.

3 Best Ice Cube Trays – Comparison & Reviews


The Essential Guide to Finding the Best Ice Cube Tray + Reviews


You do not need an ice machine to get your hands on some ice. There are plenty of good ice cube trays for sale for you to choose from. However, Grandma Jen knows how hard it may be for you to find the perfect product out of the hundreds that are available out there. That’s why we made a top of three models that will certainly catch your attention. The first product to consider is the OXO Good Grips Covered. The most important feature of this item is that the tray has a cover which makes it very easy for you to have free space in the freezer. More than that, this cover keeps the ice cubes away from other odors and prevents their absorption. This is a set of 2 ice cube trays. If this product does not suit your needs or if it is out of stock, you can check out the Elbee Home EBH-613.



Comparison table


The Good
The Bad



Our Comprehensive Buying Guide


Every individual needs an ice cube tray, since it is very practical, especially on hot summer days. However, not all the products in the line are great, and not all of them will suit your preferences and needs. More than that, you cannot just buy the first item you come across. You have to carefully pay attention to some of the most important features of an ice cube tray.

Therefore, here is a list of the aspects worth taking into account.


The capacity is the main feature of an ice cube tray. You have to consider whether it is a product that you will use many times.

Choosing one that has a large capacity and that can, therefore, hold a big number of ice cubes, means that you will have to refill the tray less often. However, if you occasionally enjoy a drink late in the evening and do not use ice cubes in other situations, then you can opt for a model that has fewer slots.



It is very uncomfortable and inconvenient if you have a tray with no cover because you will not be able to put anything on top of it and you will waste a lot of space. We would recommend you to look for a model that has a cover since it can also make transportation and storage easy, affordable and available. Moreover, a cover will prevent the ice cubes from capturing unpleasant odors that may change the taste of your drink.



Most of the items in the line are made of plastic. Cheap ice cube trays made of the mentioned material may not be the right choice for you.

The best ice cube trays will, most of the times, be made of silicone, and if this material is also BPA-free or PVC-free, the product is undoubtedly worth buying. Moreover, the silicone trays make it easier for you to remove the cubes since they are flexible and easy to maneuver.



3 Best Ice Cube Trays (Must Read Reviews)



We have carefully analyzed the importance of the features listed above and how much they can help you in the process of making and having ice cubes available. But, since we cannot make the decision in your place, we have come up with a list of products that come with some, if not all, of the features mentioned above. They have been chosen based on this and also, on the ice cube tray reviews we have found online.



1. Oxo Good Grips Covered


Have you ever been concerned with putting your usual ice cube tray into the freezer next to a pack of raw meat and it catching a bad smell? Then you should definitely take into consideration this OXO model since it has a cover that provides smell protection. The ice cubes will not capture freezer odors anymore.

Moreover, the cover is made in such a way that you can place other stuff on top. In this manner, this product won’t take a lot of space in the freezer.

The set includes 2 ice cube trays, which makes plenty of ice cubes to cool your drinks on a hot summer day or when you have a lot of guests. The model is characterized by an innovative rounded shape that makes it easy to remove the frozen water out of it.

The dimensions of this item are 13.8 x 5.7 x 3 inches. This means that you can easily measure the inside of your freezer and see how much space this tray will take up. But remember what we said earlier — you can also place other containers on top of it.


Buy from for: See the Price!




2. Elbee Home EBH-613 Set Of 2 Silicone Ice Cube Trays


If your child has not finished eating his banana mash, then you can easily put what is left of it in this Elbee Home ice cube tray and keep it in your fridge, instead of your freezer. This is because this product is specially designed for fulfilling multiple purposes.

This feature can offer you a more interesting mealtime with your baby, as he or she will find a cube of food more entertaining than usual food from a simple plate. You can even slice a strawberry, for example, and freeze it for later – or better, you can have ice cubes for your drinks that have bits of fruits in them.

The set includes two trays, each having a capacity of 15 cubes. The dimensions of a tray are 7.2 x 4.3 x 2.9 inches. They are made of premium food grade BPA free silicone. It is important because this makes the tray safe, prevents the contamination of the food and makes it durable, as well.

More than that, the silicone material offers the possibility to easily remove the ice cubes from the tray. You won’t have to twist the tray with your hands looking weird anymore. Say goodbye to this problem!   


Buy from for: See the Price!




3. Oxo Silicone Stackable 


Are you planning to travel somewhere by car and do not have an ice cube tray to take with you? Then this OXO product may be a good choice for you since the base support makes it easy to be taken on the road. It is made of FDA-grade silicone, and it is also BPA-free, PVC-free and even dishwasher safe.

The model also has a cover which prevents the ice cubes from absorbing the freezer odors and leaves you more free space. More than that, if you have a mini-fridge at work, for example, and you are looking for a tray that would fit its freezer, then you might have come across the perfect model.

The dimensions of this OXO tray are 7.5 x 2.5 x 5 inches, which means that there will be enough space for other containers and even for ice pop molds.

The tray has a 6-slot capacity, and each cube is ½ cup. They can be easily removed, and it will be a pleasure to use the frozen water. The customer reviews may help you decide if this product is what you have been looking for.


Buy from for: See the Price!