This website is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission.

3 Best Egg Sandwich Makers – Comparison & Reviews


The Essential Guide to Finding the Best Egg Sandwich Maker + Reviews


Are you looking for the best egg sandwich maker? Then look no further as Grandma Jen recommends the Hamilton Beach 25475A which ensures an excellent performance at a fair cost. With this product you’ll be able to enjoy a delicious and healthy breakfast that is ready within minutes, giving you the necessary boost for a great and productive day. The cooking plate can perfectly cook a fresh egg, which you can slide out and go on adding the extra ingredients you wish, while for the top and bottom layers of your sandwiches you can get creative and try new combinations. When it comes to its maintenance, the non-stick coating it features and the dishwasher-safe elements ensure that you can clean it right away. In case the Hamilton Beach 25475 model is by any chance unavailable, the next best option is the Hamilton Beach 25490A sandwich maker as it provides you with similar benefits and results.



Comparison table


The Good
The Bad



Our Comprehensive Buying Guide


If you have ever had breakfast in Long Island, you most probably had an egg sandwich. However, the breakfast classic is not a staple only in Long Island and it is much loved all across the nation. Making an egg sandwich is not exactly rocket science, but to make one that is close to perfection, you only need the right utensil for doing so. This kind of utensil is an egg sandwich maker and it is hailed by many as being one of the best kitchen tools they use, since they can make their favorite breakfast really fast and  easy. This buying guide will give you an idea about what to look for in the best egg sandwich maker, and it will be followed by a few recommendations in regards to what models you can find out there.

A. Egg sandwich maker

Number of sandwiches

There are many models of egg sandwich makers on the market, and one thing that sets them apart is the number of sandwiches you can make in one go. Some models are designed for singles and they have only one small cooking area in which you can easily stuff all the ingredients for a delicious egg sandwich. Other models offer you the possibility to cook more than one sandwich at the same time, so if you want to cook for more than one people, it is a good idea to opt for a model like this. It all depends on your preferences and needs, and getting the right one will save you a bit of money and energy.


Heating surface

The greatest advantage of a sandwich maker is that it heats up your meal, so you can serve it hot and tasty. Also you can choose what kind of ingredients to use, so you do not have to worry about hidden calories and stuff like that. The heating surface can be made of various materials, but the most popular are cast iron and non-stick Teflon. The latter has the advantage of helping you avoid adding extra calories by greasing the cooking surface. Because it is completely non-stick, it will not burn your sandwiches, and this is an aspect important for the best waffle and sandwich maker you can find.


Ease of maintenance

Again, Teflon has the upper hand when it comes to ease of maintenance. Because it does not make food stick to its surface, this type of material is very easy to clean and to maintain in perfect working order. You will also get to use your sandwich maker more often.



3 Best Egg Sandwich Makers (Updated Reviews) in 2021



1. Hamilton Beach 25475A Breakfast Sandwich Maker


While it allows you to use any kind of bread you want, you have to consider using the ones that can fit inside its patterns.

Are you a fan of delicious egg sandwiches or you simply want to try one? Take a look at the Hamilton Beach 25475A, a sandwich maker that is ideally designed for making egg sandwiches in five minutes or less while allowing you to customize your meal in any way you’d like to. But what makes this product so special?

Well, let’s start with its cooking surfaces. The cooking plate is capable of perfectly cook a fresh egg, after which you’re able to slide it out and go about putting the extra layers you wish. As for tops and bottoms of your sandwiches you can use small bagels, biscuits, English muffins and more.

After its preheating is done place your first chosen half of bread on the bottom plate, then add any ingredients you like, lower the top ring and the cooking plate on top of which you’ll crack open the egg. For the finishing touch put the other half of bread on top of the egg and then close the lid of the sandwich maker and after all that you’ll be left with the impression that it is extremely easy to use.

When it comes to cleaning it you’ll be happy to find out that it comes with a non-sticking coating that ensures an easy to clean capability.



It has removable parts that can go into the dishwasher which means that cleaning up after making sandwiches is a breeze.

Thanks to its fast cooking time you can make enough sandwiches in a timely manner to satisfy your hungry peers.

It offers enough layers of cooking plates: the bottom and top plate plus the egg cooking one all of them ensuring a perfectly cooked sandwich.

This sandwich maker has a built-in timer that can be set at half-minute intervals and alerts you when the sandwiches are ready.

It is a kitchen apparatus that allows you to make a variety of sandwiches because it offers enough space to add what ingredients you wish.



One of the disadvantages of this sandwich maker is that it can only cook one sandwich at a time.


Buy from for: See the Price!





2. Hamilton Beach Dual Breakfast Sandwich Maker with Timer


1.Hamilton Beach 25490A Breakfast Sandwich MakerNot all sandwich makers are created equal, and even the best sandwich maker that makes delicious recipes may not be that great at making egg based recipes. This is not the case with the Hamilton Beach 25490A that comes with a particular design that allows you to assemble your egg sandwiches with great ease.

To start with the beginning, this is a really easy to use cooking appliance. You can pick any kind of fresh ingredients you want to use for your sandwiches, without relying on fast food eateries that tend to load your food with sugar and preservatives. Eggs are a good choice for breakfast as they are packed with proteins and nutrients to keep you going for the entire day. You simply put the ingredients inside the two cooking areas with the eggs on top, and then close the lid and wait for the unit to work its magic. Basically, the appliance assembles the sandwiches for you, and, within less than 5 minutes, you can take them out and serve them as they are, hot and delicious.

In case you want to make just one sandwich, it is possible, too. A good thing about the Hamilton Beach 25490A is that you do not have to stay by its side, to see when it is done cooking. The model comes with an audible timer that will let you know right away that your food is ready to be served.

Ease of maintenance is another great advantage offered by the sandwich maker reviewed here. It can be disassembled into parts and all the removable parts can be washed in your dishwasher. Because it is easy to clean, many people recommend it, whether you want to make traditional egg sandwiches or you want to try more fancy recipes.



You can choose from making just one sandwich or two sandwiches at the same time, depending on how hungry you are, or how many people need to have breakfast.

The sandwich maker allows you to use fresh ingredients, this way avoiding to eat junk food on your way to work.

The timer is a handy feature, and it comes with an audio alarm that will announce that the cooking process is over.

You will appreciate how easy it is to clean this machine, as the parts that can be taken out are dishwasher safe.

Start cooking healthy breakfasts at home with the help of the easy recipes offered with your purchase.



The lack of an on and off switch does get annoying to some degree, as you will have to plug the unit when you want to use it and unplug it when you’re done using it.

Some extra cleaning may be needed, as the unit can get a bit messy from the eggs.


Buy from for: See the Price!





3. Proctor Silex 25479 Breakfast Sandwich Maker White


This compact and affordable appliance will allow you to make a delicious, hot breakfast sandwich in just under five minutes. You simply have to choose your bread, be it a bagel, English muffin or even a pancake and layer on the fixings such as egg, cheese, precooked meat or any other ingredient of your choice.

After you’ve added the ingredients, in just a few minutes, the product will assemble your breakfast expertly so that you can have a quick and nutritious lunch for the entire family. Since you can customize your sandwich with a nearly endless variety of fresh ingredients, you will not grow tired of using this purchase any time soon.

The manufacturer also includes a list of recipes that you can try so that you can experiment with ingredients and make the most out of your new appliance. When it is time for cleanup, you won’t have to worry about dirty pans. All the removable parts of the Proctor alternative can go straight into the dishwasher.

To make things even better, all the material used in the construction of this unit are of high quality and built to last for as long as possible. Customers love the convenience of using this model and the time that it can save each morning.



This sandwich maker delivers as promised and has your breakfast ready in just 5 minutes so that you can enjoy something warm and homemade before going out the door to work.

Assembling the ingredients for obtaining delicious egg sandwiches is easy; this unit works with any bagel, pancake, or flatbread, on which you can load smoked meat, cheese, and one egg.

The model comes with a recipe booklet, allowing you to start using the machine right away, for delicious breakfast meals that are done in just a few minutes.

You can use your own ingredients and create any combination you like, while the machine takes care of putting it together.

Some of the parts can be removed and washed in your dishwasher, along with other dishes, without a problem.



The machine can get really hot, and taking the sandwich out will require you to use some mittens so that you don’t end up burning your hands.


Buy from for: See the Price!





Unavailable products


Hamilton Beach 25475


2.Hamilton Beach 25475Another contender at the title of the best egg sandwich maker is a model also manufactured by Hamilton Beach. Compared to the model reviewed above, this one is a good choice for someone living alone, because it makes just one sandwich in one go. Now, you no longer have to count on the fast food around the corner for your breakfast meals. You can just put together a delicious sandwich and let the Hamilton Beach 25475 cook it for you.

First of all, this unit works very fast and it is very convenient. It takes less than 5 minutes to have your egg sandwich done, so you can enjoy the perfect taste of this classic recipe. Once the cooking surface is well preheated, you can start by placing a slice of bread on the bottom and the rest of the ingredients on top of it, with the egg coming in last, covering by another slice of bread. Making an egg sandwich has never been easier and faster.

If you want to get really creative, you do not have to rely on the same old same old boring bread. You can make your egg sandwiches using instead English muffins, bagels, or biscuits. Anything that can be used instead of bread can be included in your original egg sandwich recipes. If you have no idea where to start, the booklet with recipes included with your purchase will help you out.

Cleaning up the unit, once you are done with it, is very easy. Unplug the appliance and let it for a while to cool down. The ring assembly is easy to remove by holding the bottom handle open and lifting it upwards. Remove the heating plates, as well, and place everything, including the body of the unit, inside your dishwasher. Your egg sandwich maker will look as good as new in no time.