This website is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission.

3 Best Carafe Coffee Makers – Comparison & Reviews


The Essential Guide to Finding the Best Carafe Coffee Maker + Reviews


If you’ve sifted through the hundreds of models available for sale nowadays and haven’t managed to find the best carafe coffee maker, you’re in the perfect place. Grandma Jen has looked at the features of most of the popular choices out there and has concluded that the model that’s truly worthy of your consideration is the OXO On Barista Brain 8710100. This choice comes with any feature you might ever want from a product in this line and something extra on the side. It’s equipped with a rainmaker shower head and a LED interface that comes with a backlit screen. There’s even a timer with the help of which you can get a fresh cup of Joe every morning. If the OXO On Barista Brain 8710100 is no longer in stock, perhaps the Moccamaster KBGT 79312 can make just good of an option.



Comparison table


The Good
The Bad



Our Comprehensive Buying Guide


In the market for the best coffee maker with carafe? If you’re finding it hard to make up your mind about a particular model, the buying guide below will help you better separate the wheat from the chaff. To make an informed decision, keep on reading.

What capacity do you need?

Most of the units available on the market today are capable of brewing anything from four to twelve cups of coffee. 9-cup and 12-cup alternatives are popular with people who want to make sure that they make enough coffee for their entire family while those outfitted with smaller capacities mostly speak to the needs of individuals who live alone or who have just one roommate.

Once you’ve made up your mind about just how much coffee you drink in a day, perhaps you should look at the size of the appliance. The bigger it is, the more countertop space it will take up.


Programming features

While some models are capable of shutting off all by themselves, others are far more cutting-edge than that. For example, there are choices that can allow you to set their timer over the course of twenty-four hours so that a fresh cup of Joe expects you whenever you need it the most.

These models surely come in handy if you hardly function when you wake up and can’t be bothered with setting the coffee machine before getting into the shower. If the appliance comes with an electronic display, it’s even better as you can find out just how you stand in terms of the time you have to wait up until everything’s ready.


Does the design matter for you?

For health-related reasons, we don’t recommend models made entirely from plastic, especially if the material isn’t BPA-free. The carafe can be made out of glass or stainless steel, depending on your preferences in this sense. The second might not be excellent if you want to see your coffee dripping into the carafe.

Many consumers recommend getting the best stainless steel carafe coffee maker because of its design and rugged build. On the one hand, such a design is beneficial as it is very likely for it to go well with the rest of your kitchen appliances. Besides, stainless steel is highly resilient and can withstand the test of time.



3 Best Carafe Coffee Makers (Updated Reviews) in 2021



While we cannot make a choice for you, we can at least suggest some models that have garnered many favorable carafe coffee maker reviews. The following selection comprises units that are critically acclaimed for a series of reasons ranging from ease of use to convenience.



1. Oxo 8710100 On Barista Brain


If you like having complete control over the coffee making process, this OXO alternative is definitely worth taking into account. The product is equipped with an intuitive LED interface that comes with a backlit screen. The info displayed relates to the status of the appliance and whether the coffee is fresh or not.

Since the Barista Brain comes with a 24h timer, you will be able to set the coffee maker per your specific needs. The unit also does a good job when it comes to heating up the water at the right temperature, mainly one that ranges from 197.6 to 204.8 degrees.

The model will offer you two to nine cups of coffee, depending on your momentary requirements. We all know that it doesn’t make sense to make too much if you’re trying to cut back on your consumption or if you live alone. However, when you have people over at your place, it sure is reassuring to know that the OXO choice can make as many as nine cups per session.

Having garnered the appreciation of over three hundred satisfied consumers, it appears as if the OXO 8710100 is worth a try.



It is a customer-friendly product that uses an intuitive LED interface with a backlit screen together with a freshness indicator that will show users the current status of the coffee maker.

The brew cycle is controlled by a microprocessor that can replicate the pour-over method to produce 2 to 9 cups of perfectly brewed and flavorful coffee each time you use it.

You can now wake up to the perfect cup of Joe by programming the coffee maker to start brewing at any time of day or night by using the 24-hour start timer.

It has a stylish construction made of a mix of brushed stainless steel and black plastic with a transparent reservoir to let you know how much water you have left. 



It is unfortunate that unlike other models in its price range, this one lacks a scale which means that it can’t detect the volume of water within its tank automatically.


Buy from for ($199.99)





2. Moccamaster KBGT 79312 Coffee Brewer 40 oz


Looking for a somewhat larger coffee maker? If you are, maybe the Moccamaster makes the right alternative for what you need and what you have in mind. The product is manufactured in the Netherlands and has been tested time and again for quality and results. It’s one of the fastest options out there, what with it being capable of brewing an entire carafe in a matter of just six minutes.

So, if you’re entertaining guests and you have to make a lot of coffee, you should consider the Moccamaster. Also, something that needs to be added with regard to this choice is that it comes with a copper boiling element that makes it possible for the water to reach the right temperatures, mainly those ranging from 196 to 205 degrees F.

The only aspect that seems to be lacking in the design of the Moccamaster is the fact that it comes with no programmability. Nonetheless, since it is made with all-metal parts, at least you have the reassurance that you won’t be drinking any coffee that has passed through plastic components.

The carafe looks great, but it will not allow you to take a peek at how things are coming along. Even with this minor drawback, the taste of the coffee brewed with the Moccamaster is delicious.



The large 40 oz. reservoir can store enough water to prepare 10 cups of delicious brew and it is made of transparent glass that lets you see how much water is left at a quick glance.

Once the unit is done brewing, the copper element will shut down automatically and the power switch will turn on to let you know that your coffee is ready to be poured into cups.

It is very easy to operate and it has a quiet yet fast brewing process that can fill a carafe to the brim in under 6 minutes.

The 9-hole outlet arm can pulse water over you coffee at a temperature of 196-205 degrees Fahrenheit to ensure a smooth and even extraction for a cup of coffee that is flavourful from the first sip to the last drop. 



The carafe is a nuisance to wash because the opening is too narrow and the water that collects inside it is hard to get out.


Buy from for ($499)





3. Bodum Bistro 11001-01TG Coffee Maker Automatic


Not all prospective buyers can afford to spend over one hundred dollars on such an appliance, which is why the Bodum Bistro is made for consumers whose budgets are a bit more limited. The fact that it is reasonably priced cannot be correlated with a lower quality, however, as the model comes with everything you need to make a more than decent coffee.

As is the case with the Moccamaster we’ve also described in our selection, this unit is capable of making an entire carafe in just about six minutes. The 1450-watt heating element that it has been outfitted with can ensure that the water temperature is on par so that your cup of Joe turns out delicious.

It’s also worth adding that the product comes with a filter made from stainless steel, so you won’t bother with getting paper ones. The glass tubing system is reliable and adds to the flavor of the coffee you will be able to enjoy. Last, but not least, the Bodum boasts a thermal carafe, which means that your drink will remain warm without becoming bitter.

Some of the consumers who were kind enough to write detailed reviews about this product say that it is great for the price as it offers plenty of value and manages to complete the coffee making process in a timely fashion.



A revolutionary feature of this model is its rubber head which showers the water onto the ground coffee uniformly to avoid too strong central flow in order to produce a balanced flavor.

The tempered glass tubing helps maintain the heat at the right temperature without affecting the flavor of the coffee.

The thermal stainless steel carafe is double-walled and it can keep the coffee hot long after the brewing process is completed without affecting the flavor or making it bitter.

It has a simple design that doesn’t try to reinvent the coffee marker, but that does manage to refine the entire process.

The low price point is another advantage of this model since it offers a lot of value and it is something we’ve noticed is mentioned in many of the customer reviews. 



The plastic mold under the pitcher tends to collect drips and it makes the cleaning process frustrating.


Click to see the price on Amazon!
 Protection Status