This website is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission.

Best butter dish


Butter dishes – Ratings & Informative guide


Everybody knows that butter is perishable and if it is not kept in the best conditions, it can make a lot of mess in the fridge and on the table. If you want to enjoy its freshness for a longer time, you should look for a good butter dish. With all the options available on the market, it is difficult to make a decision. After looking at many choices, we can mention that the Butter Bay Butter Keeper is one of the most popular ones. This item helps you store the high-fat dairy product in the best conditions and keep it fresh without refrigeration. It has a unique dishwasher-safe design, and it is made from a resistant, Lead and Cadmium-free material. If you cannot find it in your area, you can choose the another quality butter dish, the Norpro 8370. This option has similar practical features and a classical design and is made of porcelain; it is an eye-catching detail in any kitchen decor.



Products worth your attention:


The Good
The Bad



These are the aspects worth focusing on when looking for a butter dish:


A butter dish is something that we rarely think about until we need it. It can eliminate greasy messes and keep butter fresh when it is out of the fridge. Surprisingly there are several makes and models to choose from, which is why we created this helpful buying guide. In it you will find the information you need to pick the best butter dish in 2021 to fit your needs.



One of the most important aspects to consider is the size, according to the best butter dish reviews. The last thing you want is to have to spend time cutting and reforming a stick of butter just to make it fit in the dish. Most butter dishes are designed to hold ½ cup or one traditional size stick, but you can also find some that are large enough to fit ¼ lb.



Even though most butter dishes are constructed from materials that have been deemed safe for use around food, it is still a good idea to check. Plastics that are free from PBAs are always recommend, and if the butter dish is constructed from porcelain or another material you will want to ensure that it does not contain any harmful particles. It should be noted that some vintage and antique butter dishes do contain lead, and this alone is reason enough for you to consider replacing it.



If you love the design of the vintage butter dishes but want to avoid lead and other harmful contaminants you might want to consider one that comes with a French inspired design. Typically made from white porcelain, these butter dishes usually also come with a convenient lid. If you want to keep the butter out of the fridge so it is easy to spread, you can find models that are designed to hold cold water. When this is combined with the lid butter will stay soft and fresh without the need for refrigeration. You can also find butter dishes that are designed just to be functional. Typically constructed from clear plastic these dishes will keep unwrapped butter contained while it is in the fridge.



3 Best Butter Dishes (Reviews) in 2021



You can find butter dishes that match your place settings and kitchen decor or are designed simply to hold unwrapped sticks in the fridge. While we can’t choose the right model for you we can help you make an informed decision, which is why we have the best butter dish with a lid showcased below.



1. Butter Bay American Made Butter Keeper Butter Dish


1-butter-bay-americanIf you are looking for an insulated butter dish you might want to consider this attractive model by Butter Bay. Thanks to its unique design you don’t have to store it in the fridge to keep it from spoiling and melting.

The dish comes with a convenient basin that is designed to hold ¼ to ⅓ cup of cold water. This is what keeps the butter fresh without refrigeration. Since it is only kept cool, it is always easy to slice and spread. To ensure freshness, simply add fresh water every three to four days.

Cleaning the butter dish between sticks is a breeze, thanks to its dishwasher safe design. It is constructed from a durable material that is also cadmium and lead free. The lid seals tightly to prevent anything from getting inside, which is always an advantage when you leave food sitting out.

Best of all this attractive butter dish is available in several fashionable colors so you can easily find one to match your kitchen decor. It is also proudly manufactured in the U.S.A.



This product is available in five different colors, so you can pick the one that best matches the rest of your plates and cutlery.

The unique design of this dish allows you to put an entire cube of unwrapped butter safely, without creating any mess.

The basin can be filled with a ⅓ cup of cold water to keep your butter spreadable and soft at any hour of the day. Just make sure to change the water every 3-4 days to keep it fresh.

Thanks to the centuries-old French method and the hand-finished design, you won’t have to refrigerate your butter ever again.



Although made in the United States, this item didn’t convince all of the customers. Some complained about the butter reservoir being smaller than advertised, while the water reservoir was too big.

Also, make sure to carefully examine the butter keeper before accepting the delivery. Some people said the handle on the lid was cracked.


Buy from for: See the Price!





2. Norpro Porcelain Butter Dish with Lid


2-norpro-8370This is often considered the best French butter dish, and it is not hard to see why. Norpro designed it to look classic and elegant sitting on your table, while also keeping the butter contained.

It is constructed from white porcelain that is free from harmful contaminants so you can rest assured that it is safe to use to store butter. The white porcelain and the simple design of the dish ensure that it will blend in beautifully with any table setting.

Even though it has a vintage appeal it is dishwasher safe so cleaning this butter dish  is quick and easy. You do want to make sure that you place it on the top rack to prevent damage during the wash cycle. The base of the dish is slightly upturned to ensure the stick doesn’t slide off. This also helps to limit any greasy messes.

The matching porcelain lid ensures that the butter stays fresh when it is on the table, and thanks to the knob on top it is easy to lift off. It is also sized to hold a ½ cup of butter at a time.



It features a classic design that will perfectly complement the rest of your kitchen decor and accessories.

The product is made of top-quality white porcelain and comes with the perfect size to hold a stick of butter. Also, it will keep the butter cool, fresh, and easy to spread all day long. The small knob on top will help you lift the lid without a struggle and will ensure a good grip.

The dish comes with a ridge inside to prevent the butter from sliding and making a mess.

In addition, the product is dishwasher safe and easy to clean in just a matter of minutes.


Although most customers agree on the great size of this butter dish, some were not pleased with the overall quality of the product they ordered, saying it was made of a thin material that can chip or break if you don’t handle it properly.


Buy from for: See the Price!





3. Rubbermaid Standard Butter Dish


3-rubbermaid-1777193There are several reasons why this is the best plastic butter dish. You get two containers which are designed specifically for storing butter. They can hold up to a ¼ pound, which makes them a great choice for large households.

Each container is constructed from durable plastic, a material this manufacturer is well known for. These butter dishes are also free from harmful contaminants so they are safe to use.

The clear plastic lid allows you to see exactly how much of the stick is left. This way you always know when it needs to be refilled. The lid is also designed to seal tightly so your butter always stays fresh. The BPA plastic is dishwasher safe so cleaning the containers is a breeze. Though you will want to place them on the top rack to prevent any damage.

For over 80 years Rubbermaid has been creating high quality products that are designed to make life a little easier, and this includes this set of plastic butter dishes.



If you’re looking for a more efficient and less expensive alternative to regular porcelain butter dishes, this product from Rubbermaid should be your number one choice. It is made of durable and thick plastic that is resistant to chipping and it won’t break if you drop it on the floor.

It is dishwasher-safe, thus it will be ready to use again after just a few minutes.

The product is delivered in a set of two, perfect for covering the needs of large families or two tables at the same time.

The item is specifically designed to hold the butter and prevent it from slipping and causing a mess.



Although BPA-free, this plastic product will require refrigeration if you want to keep your butter fresh. Thus, the butter’s natural flavors will eventually mix with the plastic container.

Some customers who purchased this butter dish said they only received the red base, without the lid, which makes it impossible to use.


Buy from for: See the Price!