This website is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission.

5 Best Breakfast Sandwich Makers – Comparison & Reviews


The Essential Guide to Finding the Best Breakfast Sandwich Maker + Review


If you are looking for the best breakfast sandwich maker, Grandma Jen recommends the Hamilton Beach 25475 model, as it helps you get some delicious results at a fair cost. You can start your days in a great and healthy way by preparing a mouthwatering breakfast made of fresh ingredients. In the process, you might even end up saving some money, as well. The model is easy to use and you can simultaneously cook multiple ingredients by using the different layers. Once everything is in place on these, you can close the lid and in less than 5 minutes, your breakfast will be ready and you can kick-start your day. Moreover, the model is very easy to maintain and its non-stick surfaces are dishwasher-safe, so cleaning is a breeze. If the Hamilton Beach 25475 is unfortunately unavailable, the option you want to keep in mind is the Hamilton Beach 25490A as it offers similar features and benefits.



Comparison table


The Good
The Bad



Our Comprehensive Buying Guide


What better and faster idea for a filling breakfast than a couple of sandwiches on a plate? Although you can eat sandwiches all day long, or during any meal of the day, sandwiches are best for breakfast. If you want to make scrumptious sandwiches fast and easy, a good idea is to get a sandwich maker. These units are usually inexpensive and they help you warm and grill your sandwiches for a more exquisite taste. In case you are on the lookout for the best breakfast sandwich maker, the following buying guide will help you choose one that will be exactly to your liking.

A. Breakfast sandwich maker


The first thing you may notice when you go shopping for a sandwich maker is that these units come in different sizes. It is very important for you and for your budget to get one that is exactly what you need for your future breakfasts. A larger unit would be a great choice for someone who intends to feed an entire family, adults and kids alike, with sandwiches each morning. However, keep in mind that the larger units are more expensive and they also consume more electric power to function. So, if you live by yourself, a smaller sandwich maker is the clever choice.


Cooking surface

There are not many types of cooking surfaces available for the sandwich makers available on the market. Two are the most common: cast iron and Teflon. Cast iron offers the benefit of uniform heating, but it is not non-stick, and, if you have to oil it to become non-stick, you will end up adding calories to the sandwiches you are making. Teflon has the benefit, besides being non-stick, to be very easy to clean. And, as you can clean the sandwich maker easy, you will surely use the unit more often for making healthy breakfasts.


Handle quality

Another sign of the best sandwich maker is a good quality handle. This may not sound like much, but a handle that is made of poor quality materials is going to break and it will render the sandwich maker completely unusable, which means that you will have to throw it away and purchase another. Check the handle on the item you intend to purchase. If the handle is made of steel, you have a winner. By all means, stay away from models with plastic handles because these are the first to break.



5 Best Breakfast Sandwich Makers (Updated Reviews) in 2021



1. Hamilton Beach 25475 Breakfast Sandwich Maker

3.Hamilton Beach 25475 Breakfast Sandwich MakeHamilton Beach has quite a reputation for making cooking appliances that are easy and convenient to use in any kitchen. The Hamilton Beach 25475 is a very handy tool for singles who need to make just one sandwich at a time. Saving space, energy and being very easy to use, this model is highly appreciated by those who have already bought it.

Often named the best breakfast sandwich maker, this sandwich maker from Hamilton Beach lives up to expectations. You can use your own fresh ingredients for making delicious sandwiches, and you will even end up saving money in the process, since you will not be visiting fast food eateries any time soon.

The model is very easy to use. You place the first layers of the sandwich on the bottom, then you crack an egg and place it on top.

After that, you will only have to close the lid and wait for less than 5 minutes for your breakfast to be ready. Hot meals are easy to make at home, provided that you have the right tools, such as the Hamilton Beach 25475. A booklet with recipes is included for your convenience.



The unit is easy to use and quick, as it takes just 5 minutes to cook a sandwich for your breakfast meal.

The sandwich maker has removable parts, and these can be washed in a regular dishwasher without any other prerequisites, for easy cleaning.

One thing that counts as a significant plus is the non-stick coating applied on the cooking surfaces, ensuring that cleaning remains a breeze after each use.

You can use more than just bread for making your sandwiches, including English muffins and small bagels.

You will receive, along with your purchase, a guide with many recipes to get you started, in case you feel at a loss when it comes to preparing breakfast.



The depth of the compartment where you assemble the sandwich may not be enough for adding too many layers, as some buyers complain about in their reviews.


Buy from for: See the Price!





2. Hamilton Beach 25490A Dual Breakfast Sandwich Maker


1.Hamilton Beach 25490A Breakfast Sandwich MakerOne thing that people simply hate about fast food is that it comes loaded with preservatives, sugar and other chemicals that affect their health to a great extend. However, fast food has its benefits, as it is convenient and it has great taste.

Now you can enjoy all these benefits, guilt free, as the Hamilton Beach 25490A helps you make your own sandwiches and you will know exactly what goes in each of them.

The greatest thing about this unit is that it is really fast. You can cook one or two sandwich in less than 5 minutes, while you take care of other things in order to get ready for work. Because of the special design the sandwich maker has, you can cook egg sandwiches with great ease.

You only need to place the base of the sandwich on the bottom layer, add the egg and then close the lid. Your sandwiches will practically make themselves and, in just 5 minutes, you can indulge in their great taste.

The model comes with its own recipe booklet, so you can get inspired for your next breakfast. The controls are easy to use and you can dissemble the unit so you can wash the parts in your dishwasher.



This is the perfect sandwich maker if you are the kind who either likes having two sandwiches in the morning or likes sharing with someone.

The unit is fast, and it takes just 5 minutes to cook your sandwiches to perfection.

One useful feature is the timer that comes with an audible alert, to let you know when your sandwiches are done and ready to be served.

You will love the easy clean-up, as all the parts that can be removed are easy to accommodate in a dishwasher.

You will find a recipe booklet inside the package delivered to your door, which means that you can start using it right away.



Manipulating the moving parts can be a bit of a bummer since that takes some learning to get used to and master it properly.


Buy from for: See the Price!





3. Hamilton Beach 25460A Electric Panini Press


If you are the type of person who is always on the go, getting from bed straight to work ar other activities then you might be in need of a kitchen appliance that can ensure cooked food in a short amount of time. The Hamilton Beach 25460A is a sandwich maker that you should check out because it presents many advantages.

For starters, it can grill sandwiches of any thickness allowing you to use the ingredients that you want in order to make your favorite sandwich. It features a floating lid that enables you to evenly press down resulting in an ideally shaped sandwich with desirable grill marks, unlike other models who tend to ruin the shape beyond recognition.

This sandwich maker is easy to use and control. It comes equipped with power and preheat lights that let you know when it’s ready to grill. It provides plenty of space with its big cooking surface, allowing two or three sandwiches at the same time.

Also, if you’ve had it with sandwiches for a while you can try to cook other dishes, like paninis, quesadillas, pizza and so on, all that thanks to the lock hinge on the unit that is designed to allow the lid to hover over the toppings and not interfere by coming in contact.



The Hamilton Beach 25460A is a sandwich maker that allows an even distribution of heat which results in perfectly cooked sandwiches.

Thanks to its floating lid, you will have ideally shaped sandwiches without having to worry about ruining them when trying to peel them off because the grids are also non-stick coated.

It is a versatile kitchen appliance that can cook not only delicious sandwiches but also quesadillas, pizza or paninis, meaning that you can host a veritable party with its help.

Because it can be easily stored in an upright position this product can be placed aside conveniently without taking too much space.

It offers a relatively large cooking surface which means that you can make sandwiches for two or three people at the same time, without leaving someone behind.



One user complained that there is no temperature adjustment feature, although agreeing that it provides good value for the money.


Buy from for: See the Price!





4. Proctor Silex 25408 Sandwich Toaster


Are you looking for a handy kitchen appliance that doesn’t take much space and offers plenty of choices to cook? Then you should take a look at the Proctor Silex 25408 because it is a versatile sandwich maker that can make sandwiches, omelets, french toast or other dishes in a fast and easy way.

It is small enough for easy storage in an upright position while still offering enough space to cook two regular sandwiches at a time. This product features a non-sticking surface which means that you won’t go through much of a hassle while trying to clean it.

It is an easy to use toaster thanks to its indicator lights that let you know when the power is on or when it is ready to cook and it has a convenient cord wrap feature that is placed in the back so its 24-inch cord doesn’t get in the way. Also, it has a heat resistant handle which may come as good news for those who don’t tend to pay much attention.

Because of its capability to evenly spread the temperature along the cooking surfaces, you would be able to enjoy nice results. So, if you don’t have the room or the budget to spare on other cooking devices you might enjoy the Proctor Silex 25408.



It provides plenty of space for cooking two sandwiches at the same time as well as options for other types of meals.

This product is suitable for one- to two-person households that don’t have too much room to spare on kitchen appliances, being able to be easily stored in an upright position

Its cooking surfaces distribute the heat evenly from side to side, thus creating perfectly cooked sandwiches in a short amount of time.

It is an easy to clean sandwich toaster thanks to non-sticking grids, meaning that you won’t spend great amounts of time on scraping hardened food debris.

The Proctor Silex 25408 is an easy to use product that doesn’t require much attention to be paid because it lets you know when it’s ready to cook with power on & preheat lights.



For those who would like a grilled surface on their sandwiches or paninis, it might come as an unpleasant surprise that this product doesn’t have grilled ridges.


Buy from for: See the Price!





5. ZZ S61421 3 in 1 Sandwich Waffle


2.ZZ S61421 Sandwich Waffle and Breakfast MakerIn case you are looking for the best panini sandwich maker, this model is a very good choice. Because of its particular design, it allows you to make all kinds of breakfast foods, including waffles.

The ZZ S61421 is very helpful at putting together tasty meals fast and easy, and the greatest part is that you do not have to spend a lot of time cleaning after it. All its heating plates are non-stick and can be removed for cleaning once you are done. If you dislike doing the dishes by hand, it serves to know that the heating plates are completely dishwasher safe.

People who have already tried the ZZ S61421 are delighted with the array of breakfast foods they can make with this model. Sandwiches, Panini sandwiches and waffles are among the types of meals you can easily cook with the help of this sandwich maker.

The model comes equipped with power on and pre heat lights that will let you know when you can start cooking. Now you no longer have to go to your local fast food for a tasty sandwich.

Another feature that must be mentioned about the ZZ S61421 is that it has a cord wrap feature and it can be store vertically so you can save up space.



You can use this unit to make sandwiches or waffles, and its versatility will bring more customization and possibilities to your morning meals.

The cooking plates are non-stick, which means that you don’t risk burning your sandwiches, and the cleaning process is easy.

The unit has indicator lights that will let you know when the machine is on, and when it is pre-heating so you can start the cooking process.

The model stores compactly, since it has a small footprint on your kitchen counter, and it can even be stored upright, with its cord well wrapped for convenience.

The handle remains cool to the touch during operation, so you don’t risk burning your hands.



The cord is on the short side, which means that you will either have to use an extension or find a place for the unit next to a power outlet.


Buy from for: See the Price!