This website is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.


Automatic sandwich makers – Ratings & Informative Guide


Want to make sure that you’re getting the best automatic sandwich maker but hardly know what to expect from such an appliance? Rest assured, Grandma Jen has you covered. She recommends the Hamilton Beach 25490 as it’s convenient and ready to go in as little as two minutes. With the help of this appliance, you will make the most out of your mornings and prepare as many as two layered sandwiches per cooking session. Besides, you might want to know that all of the parts that can be removed from this model can be cleaned in the dishwasher. You can use a variety of ingredients with this appliance, so the sky’s the limit as to how creative your sandwiches can get. If you have no means of trying out the Hamilton Beach 25490, perhaps you might want to consider the second best choice, the Hamilton Beach 25460A.



Products worth your attention:


The Good
The Bad



These are the aspects worth focusing on when looking for an automatic sandwich maker


Getting the best sandwich maker machine these days can be quite an adventure as the market is overflowing with good-quality alternatives that you simply must bear in mind. If you find that you’re feeling a bit baffled because of the vast array of products available for sale out there, maybe you should have a look at the following buying guide.

Selecting the right design

When it comes to the way these appliances are made, you might reach the conclusion that they do not boast the same design. Some are just more versatile than others and can be used for a broad variety of tasks. Typically, you have two choices. You either select a three or four in one model that enables you to prepare layered sandwiches, or you opt for the panini press or griddle alternative.

If you have a larger family or intend to cook different types of food as well as sandwiches at the same time, the panini press might be a better alternative for you. If, on the other hand, you’re always on the run and have little to no time to make your sandwich, choose the multi-purpose appliance.


Ease of cleaning

The best automatic sandwich maker reviews recommend that some or most of the components in the machine are dishwasher-safe. Even if you don’t have a dishwasher, you need to make sure that the plates and other removable parts come with a non-stick coating. This way, you’ll avoid damaging them and you won’t be forced to spend too much time with the whole cleanup process.



While some models can prepare up to two sandwiches, others have bigger cooking surfaces. As mentioned above, panini presses can enable you to prepare multiple sandwiches at the same time. With a multi-purpose model, however, you’ll be able to place all your ingredients, wait for five minutes, and then have a perfectly crafted layered sandwich for you to enjoy.

When trying to decide on one model over the next, it’s important to try to make an assessment and determine the amount of space you have available in your kitchen. If you live in a small apartment, the last thing you might want to do is take up even more room on your counter.



3 Best Automatic Sandwich Makers (Reviews) in 2020



If you are curious as to which models are the critically acclaimed ones available these days and which ones you can do without, you might want to have a look at the following selection. Based on what we found about them, these appliances are user-friendly and can help you eat and live healthier.



1. Hamilton Beach Dual Breakfast Sandwich Maker with Timer


If your family is somewhat small or you’re a college student who doesn’t need an overly bulky appliance in the kitchen, perhaps the 25490 is just the right choice for you. It’s compact and versatile and can allow you to prepare up to two layered sandwiches at the same time.

It doesn’t take a lot of time for the cooking surface to become hot, but since the model boasts easy to read light indicators, you’ll be able to take the guesswork out of making your sandwiches. Something that needs to be added in relation to this option is that all of its removable components can be washed with ease either by hand or by using a dishwasher.

The neat thing about the plates is that they can be used with a plethora of ingredients ranging from eggs to fresh vegetables and specialty meats. If you’re into multitasking, you’re going to enjoy the timer with an audible tone that this model comes equipped with.

As the 25490 has received the widespread appreciation of over one thousand customers, it’s safe to say that it is at least worth looking into. Most of those who have bought it say that it’s worth its weight in gold.


Buy from for ($51.98)





2. Hamilton Beach Electric Panini Press Grill With Locking Lid


Despite being one of the most affordable alternatives on the market today, the 25460A is versatile and convenient alike. Thanks to its unique design, it is entirely capable of grilling sandwiches of various sizes, which means that you’ll be able to use fresh baguettes, bagels, or any other specialty breads of your choice.

The model features a cafe-style floating lid that makes it possible for your sandwiches to come out evenly toasted. While the grids have been coated with a nonstick layer, it should be noted that this particular option does not feature removable grill plates. What this means is that you’ll have to clean them manually once you’re done with preparing your sandwiches.

Given that the unit boasts power and preheat lights, you’ll know the right time when you can place the ingredients and wait for a little while before you enjoy your breakfast or snack. What’s more, the appliance doesn’t even take up a lot of room in your kitchen as the upright storage made available by the design makes it easy to fit any countertop.

Most of the buyers who have expressed their opinions about this product say that the cooking surfaces are easy to clean and that they truly are nonstick.


Buy from for ($33.99)





3. Proctor Silex Sandwich Toaster Omelet And Turnover Maker


There are several reasons you might have to consider this model. On the one hand, it is significantly more budget-friendly compared to some of the other options we have stumbled upon while doing our research on the matter. Secondly, it’s worth noting that this is one of those simple appliances that are extremely easy to utilize and won’t raise any technical difficulties to anyone, be they tech-savvy or not.

As with the other choices we have talked about, the 25408 has been outfitted with a nonstick grid that can be cleaned both efficiently and easily. Much like some Hamilton Beach alternatives, this Proctor Silex one can be stored upright, which means that you’ll be able to save some of the space you have available in your kitchen.

The cooking plates are not removable, which is why you will not be able to clean them using the dishwasher. If this is a deal-breaker for you, it’s easy to see that this model is not made for your expectations.

The critical acclaim gathered by the 25408 comes from over four hundred satisfied customers who were kind enough to provide favorable reviews. If a no muss, no fuss appliance that doesn’t cost a lot of money is what you’re searching for, you may want to give some thought to this one.


Buy from for ($21.78)




1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (1 votes, average: 5.00 out of 5)
Loading... Protection Status